The Art of Screen Time: How Your Family Can Balance Digital Media and Real Life
See a Trouble?
Cheers for telling us near the trouble.
Friend Reviews
Reader Q&A
Community Reviews
I received an ARC from NetGalley. The book volition be released on January 30, 2018.
This volume tin can be summed upwards in the quote the author adapted from food writer Michael Pollan: "Enjoy screens. Not too much. By and large with others." It is full of research studies and is presented in a readable manner.I received an ARC from NetGalley. The book will exist released on January 30, 2018.
...more than
Kamenetz's normally hard-hitting, no-nonsense tone has softened a bit in this new book. Parenthood tin can do that to you lot, every bit I take learned. The overall tone of the book aims for balance, merely I think it strays a bit as well far on the side of permissiveness. I was surprised a
I've been following Kamenetz since the publication of DIY U, which I highly recommend to anyone who has a pale in college and university life in the The states. Seriously. Finish reading this review and go get it right now, Nammy.Kamenetz's normally hard-hitting, no-nonsense tone has softened a bit in this new volume. Parenthood can practise that to you, as I accept learned. The overall tone of the volume aims for rest, merely I call back it strays a bit too far on the side of permissiveness. I was surprised at the resignation coming through in many of the passages, even though information technology was once in a while tempered by things like "we in one case idea smoking was too big an event to take on, and we have culturally completely reformed our habits in that regard."
The central analogy of the volume is that screens are like food. There are healthy, nourishing kinds of food, and then in that location are take-out and drive-through meals. No one dies from eating a single Whopper, so we should probably all chill out. And for heaven'southward sake, nosotros need to cease shaming people when a Happy Meal seems like the best option they take; it'south certainly better than starving. I go that, mostly, merely I recall it plays into almost middle- and upper-eye class people's (the target audience) ability to rationalize and make excuses for their shortcomings.
In way, she has to have that position, because nosotros all have an awful lot of screen-related shortcomings. And so it does make sense to say that the data is inconclusive about how harmful it is or how helpful it might exist. The publishing bias means that more negative stories are printed than positive ones, simply fifty-fifty without the formalized, academy-based strong arm of research, well-nigh people demand to look no further than their habits to see that what they thought was a tool is really a crutch. It's just hard to say that without freaking people out, peculiarly vulnerable parents of immature kids, among whom Kamenetz counts. And then she doesn't meet it.
Instead of relying on decades of inquiry by Sherry Turkle, whose studies Kamenetz deems "anecdotal and over-interpreted" (I've read them and disagree), she defers to the opinions of danah boyd, an anthropologist who works for Microsoft, though that last bit is left out. boyd's positions seem to me far more anecdotal than Turkle's, but they are more than palatable, and then they seem to win out.
Despite the skew toward permissiveness, I think Kamenetz gives a lot of actionable steps that parents can accept to found a more than meaningful family unit life, 1 that is less dominated by passive forms of digital consumption. The last three pages of the book are the TL;DR list of suggestions, so if you lot're interested, have at information technology.
...more than
I think the gist is similar to virtually things, moderation is key. Limiting screen fourth dimension is ever recommended, along with what screen time you let, you lot actively participate with the children during the duration. Screens and technology no affair how avant-garde are non babysitters, and should not be used as such.
At that place are one too many product comparisons, bordering on subtle endorsement.
This volume is American centere Anya Kamenetz is a slap-up writer, but early in the book she goes afterwards my dear Sherry Turkle, which enticed me to scrutinize every word, sentence, and source in search of a weakness. Simply alas, I could not find too many. This is the guidebook parents we need for at present if y'all are looking for a touchstone in dealing with digital anxiety. Simply since I took the devils pill, here are my nit-pics:
In that location are 1 too many product comparisons, bordering on subtle endorsement.
This book is American centered - nix from Asian or African communities who deal with the same issues.
Despite calling Turkle "Antidotal," the author (cocky admittedly) packages her research with speculative analogy.
Doesn't deal with the white elephant in the room: negotiating with a whining adolescent over where to put their eyes.
But this volume isn't nigh controlling beliefs- information technology's well-nigh what yous tin do at present, based on assay from all of the experts in the western world, written in a way that informs without terrorizing.
...more
Realistically looks at the fact that mobile devices and the internet are not going abroad and real people apply them for good purposes throughout the day.
A TL;DR section at the end summarizes the book nicely if due south
Is it the best. Book. Ever? No. Merely it does exactly what it sets out to do and explains what enquiry actually says, and does not say virtually the furnishings of screen time on kids, likewise and discusses what various experts say well-nigh their research and what they do about screens in their homes.Realistically looks at the fact that mobile devices and the cyberspace are not going abroad and real people use them for good purposes throughout the day.
A TL;DR department at the end summarizes the book nicely if storylines, anecdotes and quotations are not your thing.
Personally, I am not going to worry about any screen time when it is being used as digital paper; ie, reading a book, looking up cool facts, or learning how to practice something, unless it's also close to bedtime. Interactive utilise will exist prioritized above passive employ, but I'll keep an eye out for games that get compulsive. Devices should exist charged in the kitchen.
This goes for my kids also. ;)
...more than
I constitute the most interest part of the boo
Every bit someone who must have at least a low-cal addiction to technology, I found this book very interesting. Kamenetz actually focuses on the advice: "Enjoy fourth dimension with screens; generally with others; not too often". When she focuses on that thesis, I notice the volume to be really good. I also appreciate how often she reiterates that some studies don't necessarily testify casualty and reminds parents that are no perfect solutions and most parents are only doing their all-time.I found the almost interest part of the book to be the confessions of inferiority she feels when reading mommy blogs and Instagram-famous mom accounts on social media.
Honestly really good stuff that made me think a lot about myself my coming son.
...more than
Then she shares her ain theory near screen fourth dimension, which I found rather interesting and valid enough. She says screens are kind of like junk food. It's all nigh moderation and non abstinence. Sort of like dieting
I read this book after changing the screen time rules in our house. I was curious nigh other's ideas on the topic, and I'd heard about this volume from ii sources recently. Anya starts the book with the research on the impact of screen time on kids, which is rather scarce and unreliable.Then she shares her own theory nearly screen time, which I constitute rather interesting and valid plenty. She says screens are kind of similar junk food. It's all virtually moderation and not abstinence. Sort of similar dieting vs. avoiding cigarettes all together.
She shares stories from her own family unit and data from an extensive survey she conducted online. And she besides talks about adults' utilize of screens. I discussed more virtually my impressions almost this book on my other web log, Mom's Radius.
http://opinionatedbooklover.com/recen...
...more than
This was a informal, non-judgy and up to the minute take on how to maintain balance with regard to media. Overall, a good read with a elementary message, a riff on Michael Pollen's food rules, "Enjoy screens, not also much, mostly with others."
Really enjoying this i. And so far, it has addressed technology utilize across early childhood, relevant to me as a new parent, and in schools, relevant to me as a public school employee. The adjacent section addresses adult use of screens *gulp.*
*Update*This was a breezy, non-judgy and up to the minute have on how to maintain balance with regard to media. Overall, a good read with a simple message, a riff on Michael Pollen's food rules, "Savor screens, not too much, more often than not with others."
Really enjoying this one. So far, information technology has addressed technology use across early babyhood, relevant to me every bit a new parent, and in schools, relevant to me as a public schoolhouse employee. The next section addresses developed use of screens *gulp.*
...more than
We rarely use a screen as a babysitter. And we set consequent limits on YouTube and the like. But nosotros (the grownups) often hav
This book caught my middle at the library so I thought I'd check it out. I've never been worried about my kids and screens. It's the reality of this globe. Screens are part of my piece of work and their school and I strongly believe that if they don't know how to use engineering science information technology will set them backside. But I have family that feels differently and yous tin can experience their judgment on us.We rarely utilise a screen as a babysitter. And we set consistent limits on YouTube and the like. Only nosotros (the grownups) often have the Television on as background noise and we're regularly reading on our phones (news, books, etc; merely you lot my non know what I'm reading from afar). It would exist hypocritical to say "no screen" to the kids when I have a screen in my hand.
I really like that this is non just the writer's stance just is many opinions, including those of actual experts (east.g., medical doctors, psychologists, etc) some conflicting simply still well researched.
Overall, I reflected on my own screen usage in their presence (information technology may not change merely I'thou more aware) and I was able to get some good ideas that go with our existing parenting style. I don't want to police force my children - now or in the future, unless they give me a reason to non non trust them. Only engaging with them most media use (be it YouTube, Netflix or a video game) similar to the manner we engage about a soccer game or concert really makes sense.
Advocating curiosity in an undoubtedly tech savvy globe rather than fearfulness will but assist my kids and we can't escape the fact that we live in an internet based world. So allow's worry more about doing something good and useful with that fourth dimension instead of exactly how much time we spend at the screen.
...more than
Certain parts of the volume are terribly difficult to read (i.e. boring) because they are like a long blog postal service filled with research statistics and reporting, ofttimes
The tagline of this volume says "How Your Family unit Tin Residuum Digital Media & Real Life", simply there's not much insights about how you tin can actually practise this. Instead, the majority of the discussion is about how schools were using EdTech, and by that extension, screen time - in schools. Information technology's a digression and should probably be the topic of another book.Sure parts of the book are terribly hard to read (i.east. boring) considering they are like a long blog post filled with research statistics and reporting, often accompanied by the author's own "unscientific survey" and anecdotes.
"A lot of research, in social club to go published, they focus on the harm."
This particular quote by Dan Romer, director of the Adolescent Communication Institute at the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania, probably underlined the author's mindset.
Central to Romer's observation is that experiments that show correlations between screens and negative furnishings receive more attention than experiments that show goose egg conclusive, and those that prove benefits are less likely to be conceived or conducted in the first place.
It is with this belief that the author tends to diss inquiry that is in favour of the former.
Using the example of "The Mom with Her Telephone at the Playground", the author raised concerns well-nigh distracted parenting, but and so quickly sounded defensive in the rest of the chapter (Chapter 7).
...more than
I found this to be a fabulous book that walks a middle path between technophobia and technoutopianism. The author is a mother and reporter who did a lot of research and interviewed experts property a variety of opinions. She also surveyed hundreds of parents and seemed to have interviewed dozens of them.
What emerges is a volume that carefully lays out the show for the harms and benefits of screen fourth dimension, distinguishes between types of scree
Full disclosure: I am childless. Accept that as y'all will.I found this to be a fabulous volume that walks a middle path between technophobia and technoutopianism. The author is a female parent and reporter who did a lot of enquiry and interviewed experts holding a variety of opinions. She also surveyed hundreds of parents and seemed to have interviewed dozens of them.
What emerges is a book that advisedly lays out the prove for the harms and benefits of screen time, distinguishes betwixt types of screen time and asks parents to inventory and exist wise about their ain screen fourth dimension. The book has an all-encompassing notes section and a good alphabetize.
Throughout the book Ms. Kamenetz emphasizes the desirability of parental involvement while recognizing limits on parents due to work and stress. She offers practical suggestions for talking about what kids are doing on the internet without putting them under surveillance. At that place are also articulation activities proposed. Along the way she examines types of parenting and questions the extreme "zipper parenting" that has generated a lot of "mom shaming."
If yous're looking for a clear-headed examination of problems surrounding children's utilise of electronic devices, tips on parenting kids in a digital age or fifty-fifty a reality check on your digital usage, I think this volume is for you.
...more than
Problems covered in this include direction of screen time (should you exercise it via time limits or contents, should it be reward based, should it be free from scrutiny), education and screens (including apps that can be used at abode, and how education is pragmatically being used in many classrooms for good and bad), how to bond through screen fourth dimension, and parental use and guidance.
I think my review would be closer to iv.5 out of five stars. Many people knocked stars off considering of her criticism of Sherry Turkle, who I have not read. However, I constitute the data that Kamenetz presented almost how we just DON'T know what kind of damage our new social, screen-centric guild is causing to be very compelling. Overall, an splendid and quick read for anyone (aka everyone), who exists in a globe with screens and wants to examine their choices.
...more I establish this book to be well-researched and reasonable and reassuring. Technology/screen time is a real event for all modern families, and I felt like her approach offered real data without all of the panic and controversy that is often prevalent in social media (truthfully, the effects of screen time are very difficult to inquiry). Basically, screens are here to stay, and nosotros can use common sense and embrace the skilful that they have to offer "Enjoy screens; non too much; mostly together."
I found this book to be well-researched and reasonable and reassuring. Technology/screen time is a real result for all mod families, and I felt like her approach offered real information without all of the panic and controversy that is often prevalent in social media (truthfully, the effects of screen time are very hard to research). Basically, screens are here to stay, and we tin can use mutual sense and embrace the good that they have to offering, remembering moderation and a focus on priorities (moving our bodies everyday, encouraging inventiveness and pro-social behaviors). She encourages families to appoint in media together, and to found family guidelines for proper media utilize (which may or may not include rules for time and content and observing certain screen gratis times like family dinner). Warning signals such equally weight gain, sleeplessness, hyperactivity, irritability, school trouble, mood swings, low, etc, may be a adept cue to take a screen pause.
"Yous will be more constructive as a parent and have more fun every bit a family, if yous drib the guilt and cover the skilful that screens take to offer, while balancing media with other priorities."
...more
This is the offset parenting book that not did not just read, only rather devoured. I took copious notes, went back to earlier chapters after gleaning some insight in a chapter I was currently reading, and in the terminate realized I must have "read" the book a half dozen times in the process. It is a well researched slice on the impact of digital media in our modern day life.
While it should b
The whole volume can be summed up in this quote by the author, "Savour screens. Not too much. Mostly with others."This is the kickoff parenting book that not did not just read, but rather devoured. I took copious notes, went back to earlier chapters afterward gleaning some insight in a chapter I was currently reading, and in the stop realized I must take "read" the volume a half dozen times in the procedure. Information technology is a well researched slice on the impact of digital media in our modern twenty-four hour period life.
While it should be obvious that every family is different, the author goes out of her way to state in many different means that your mileage will vary with how you lot read and implement this book. My biggest take away from all of this is that my own behavior will ultimately be the model upon which my children view their relationship with screens and digital media, and how those can exist woven into their own daily routines.
Really amazing book, and well worth the time to read it.
...more 
The most important slice of information is that screens should be used (like anyth
This book was not bad because information technology took some great enquiry and summarized it for your every day parent. I liked the book considering it hit on the effect of screen time on slumber, mood, and relationships. While the book was filled with great information - I liked the TLDR (Too Long Didn't Read) section in the dorsum the most. It highlighted each of the important points in a few minutes and are the all-time takeaways for parents.The most important piece of information is that screens should be used (like anything) in moderation. Furthermore, screens should exist used with other people and to promote skills that we want to see our children develop. I particularly enjoyed the chapter on where screens are headed (e.g., virtual reality, augmented reality, and artificial intelligence).
This book is parents who are open to chat about screen employ.
...more
It was in the parenting section of my library, and the offset several capacity are focused on research related to kids and screens, screens in educational activity, and how a survey of families navigate usage guidelines for the kids. The last affiliate or two is on parents and how our screen usage interacts with kid engagement and modeling the kin
A useful, balanced survey of the research (such every bit it is) and the opportunities of technology, especially in the course of screens, in the lives of American families.It was in the parenting section of my library, and the first several chapters are focused on enquiry related to kids and screens, screens in education, and how a survey of families navigate usage guidelines for the kids. The last chapter or two is on parents and how our screen usage interacts with kid engagement and modeling the kinds of uses we want them to emulate.
It's balanced and helpful and I don't know if it's going to alter my lazy "just say no except when I am desperate (ill days, waiting at the doctor's function, flights)" approach to my kids and screens. But information technology's got a lot of practiced nutrient for idea.
...more than
The only thing that actually struck me every bit new was a proposed culling to attachment parenting called Resources for Baby Educarers. Instead of constantly wearing a child, for case, a parent wou
I appreciated that this was non-alarmist treatment of the issue. However, I didn't walk away with many nuggets of how parents should approach screen fourth dimension beyond, "Savor screens; not also much; mostly together." What Kamenetz did offer was cautioning parents to be more aware of THEIR use of screen time.The only thing that really struck me as new was a proposed alternative to attachment parenting called Resources for Infant Educarers. Instead of constantly wearing a child, for example, a parent would stick them in a rubber, enclosed place with a few unproblematic items and let them explore. Perhaps this doesn't seem innovative to about, but it is certainly different from how I approached things.
...more
Approach digital media similar yous would arroyo food:
1. Enjoy Screens
ii. Not too much
3. Mostly with Others
2 things to e'er aim for in youth media consumption:
Active over Passive
* Parents and adults tin play a strong role in
Arroyo digital media like you lot would arroyo food:
1. Enjoy Screens
ii. Not also much
3. Mostly with Others
Two things to always aim for in youth media consumption:
Active over Passive
* Parents and adults can play a strong role in how children engage with their media, children as young as 12 months old accept been shown to mimic adults watching behaviors while watching TV
* Even video games tin can be OK as long equally parents engage with the child and testify an arroyo of mindfulness to video game playing (some examples: "So what is going on in this scene", "Oh that cat is just like our cat", "Why did our character react that way"
* Be active in speaking with child while they are playing to help develop thinking skills to what's going on in the screen
* Children are easily swayed by content (junk food ads, vehement language or scenes), make sure you lot know what children as interacting with because media tin be educational, developmental, and positive if used properly.
Social over Solo
* Don't recollect that digital media should merely exist a time to distract children to keep them busy, endeavour to engage with them as much as possible. The more than media is used as a grouping/family activity, the amend children develop their social-emotional skills. Specific media such as video chats assistance too.
Judging by the championship and subtitle, I thought there would be more practical advice for parents but if you really don't take time, y'all tin can skip str
You get a lot of valuable and interesting information about the use of devices and the Cyberspace and how it can benefit your family or otherwise, written in a readable and engaging fashion.. The utilize of technology by parents themselves and the effects are also talked near. The author did a lot of research and conducted many, many interviews for this book.Judging by the championship and subtitle, I idea in that location would exist more practical communication for parents just if you really don't have time, you can skip direct to Chapter 10 for the practical stuff.
Thank you NetGalley and the publisher for the review copy. Sorry it took so long just this is my honest review.
...more
I had my xiii-year-former read this book and do a written report on it. I required a pocket-size review of each chapter and then a determination that included his own recommendations for screens/limits in our family.
This is a great resource fo
This is the best screen/parenting book I've looked at. The writer covered the physical and emotional touch of screens. Overall, the tone was very counterbalanced—no fear mongering, just a helpful review of the facts and data. My favorite part was chapter 10 which was a TL;DR summary.I had my 13-year-one-time read this book and do a study on it. I required a pocket-sized review of each chapter and then a decision that included his ain recommendations for screens/limits in our family unit.
This is a great resource for all parents navigating a screen-filled world.
...moreHer forthcoming volume, The Art of Screen Time (PublicAffairs, 2018) is the first, essential, don't-panic guide to kids, parents, and screens. You can preorder it at present!
Generation Debt (Riverhead, 2006), dealt with youth economics and politics; DIY U: Edupunks, Edupreneurs, and the Coming Transformation of College Education (Chelsea Dark-green, 2010),
Anya is endlessly curious nigh learning and the future.Her forthcoming book, The Art of Screen Fourth dimension (PublicAffairs, 2018) is the offset, essential, don't-panic guide to kids, parents, and screens. You tin can preorder it at present!
Generation Debt (Riverhead, 2006), dealt with youth economic science and politics; DIY U: Edupunks, Edupreneurs, and the Coming Transformation of Higher Education (Chelsea Green, 2010), investigated innovations to accost the crises in price, admission, and quality in higher education. The Test (PublicAffairs, 2015), is about the past, nowadays and futurity of testing in American schools.
Learning, Liberty and the Web, The Edupunks' Guide, and the Edupunks' Atlas are her free spider web projects about self-directed, web-enabled learning.
Anya is the atomic number 82 digital instruction correspondent for NPR. Her team's blog is at NPR.org/ed. Previously she covered technology, innovation, sustainability and social entrepreneurship for 5 years as a staff author for Fast Company mag. She's contributed to The Village Vocalisation, The New York Times, The Washington Post, New York Mag, Slate, and O, the Oprah Magazine.
She was named a 2010 Game Changer in Instruction by the Huffington Post and won 2009, 2010, and 2022 National Awards from the Education Writers Clan. NPR Ed won a 2022 Edward R. Murrow award for Innovation from the Radio Television Digital News Clan.
She appears in the documentaries Generation Next (2006), Default: A Student Loan Documentary (2011), both shown on PBS, and Ivory Tower, distributed past Participant Media.
Anya grew up in Louisiana, in a family of writers and mystics, and graduated from Yale University in 2002. She lives in Brooklyn with her hubby and two daughters.
...more thanNews & Interviews
Welcome dorsum. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads business relationship.
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35099778-the-art-of-screen-time
0 Response to "The Art of Screen Time: How Your Family Can Balance Digital Media and Real Life"
Post a Comment